should however have a comma either side

Karacvop

4 min read

·

27-11-2024

2

0

Share

The Comma's Conundrum: Should "However" Have Commas on Both Sides?

The humble comma. A tiny mark of punctuation, yet it holds the power to dramatically alter the meaning and clarity of a sentence. One particularly contentious comma placement involves the word "however." Should it be nestled between commas, like a precious jewel in a setting ("However, the data suggests otherwise."), or should it stand alone, bold and unadorned ("However the data suggests otherwise.")? The answer, as with many grammatical questions, is nuanced and depends heavily on context. Let's delve into this punctuation puzzle, examining the rules and exceptions, and clarifying when those commas are truly necessary.

Understanding "However" as a Conjunctive Adverb

The key to understanding the comma rules surrounding "however" lies in recognizing its grammatical function. "However" is a conjunctive adverb – a word that connects independent clauses while also showing a relationship of contrast or concession between them. Other examples of conjunctive adverbs include "therefore," "moreover," "nevertheless," and "consequently." These words function similarly to coordinating conjunctions (like "and," "but," "or"), but they require a bit more punctuation finesse.

The Standard Rule: Commas on Both Sides

The generally accepted rule is that when "however" acts as a conjunctive adverb connecting two independent clauses, it should be set off by commas on both sides. This creates a clear pause, emphasizing the contrasting or qualifying relationship between the clauses.

Example: The experiment initially failed; however, the researchers persevered and ultimately achieved a breakthrough.

Here, "however" links two complete sentences ("The experiment initially failed" and "the researchers persevered and ultimately achieved a breakthrough"). The comma after "failed" signals the end of the first clause, and the comma after "however" marks the break before the second clause begins. This structured punctuation enhances readability and ensures clarity. Note that this same structure would hold true if you replaced "however" with other conjunctive adverbs like "therefore," "moreover," or "nevertheless."

Exceptions to the Rule: When Commas Aren't Necessary

While the double-comma rule is prevalent, there are exceptions. The necessity of commas depends entirely on the sentence's structure and the role of "however" within it.

• "However" at the Beginning of a Sentence: When "however" starts a sentence, it's typically followed by a comma. This signals the start of a new independent clause, even without a preceding clause.

Example: However, the current evidence is insufficient to draw firm conclusions.

• "However" as a Sentence Modifier: If "however" modifies a single word or phrase within a sentence, rather than connecting independent clauses, it doesn't require surrounding commas.

Example: The results, however surprising, were ultimately consistent with the hypothesis.

In this instance, "however surprising" acts as a parenthetical phrase modifying "results," not connecting two separate clauses. The commas surrounding the phrase are there to set off the parenthetical element, but the "however" itself does not necessitate additional commas.

• Short, Simple Sentences: In very short, simple sentences, omitting the second comma might be acceptable for stylistic reasons, although the double-comma structure remains grammatically correct.

Example: The project is challenging; however it is also rewarding.

While grammatically permissible to add a comma after "however," the sentence's brevity might make the second comma feel slightly awkward.

Addressing Potential Ambiguity: Why Commas Matter

The correct use of commas with "however" is crucial for preventing ambiguity and ensuring clear communication. Consider these examples:

Ambiguous: However the data suggests otherwise it's important to note the limitations of the study.

Corrected: However, the data suggests otherwise, it's important to note the limitations of the study. (This version clearly connects "the data suggests otherwise" and "it's important to note...")

Or: However the data suggests otherwise, it’s important to consider alternative explanations. (This version emphasizes the contrast between the data and the need for alternative explanations)

The placement of the commas drastically alters how the sentence is understood. The ambiguous version is difficult to interpret without careful reading, whereas the corrected versions clearly convey the intended meaning. The correct use of commas improves the overall flow, readability, and clarity of your writing.

Practical Applications and Examples from Research Literature

Let's examine how this rule plays out in the context of scientific writing, drawing upon (hypothetical) examples inspired by research articles you might find on platforms like ScienceDirect. (Note: The following examples are illustrative and not drawn directly from specific ScienceDirect publications, to avoid potential copyright issues.)

Example 1 (Correct): "The control group showed no significant change in blood pressure; however, the experimental group exhibited a marked decrease. This suggests the treatment is effective." (This correctly separates two independent clauses using commas around “however.”)

Example 2 (Correct): "The findings were, however, unexpected in light of previous research." (Here, "however" modifies the adjective "unexpected" and does not require commas on both sides.)

Example 3 (Incorrect): "The sample size was small; however the results were statistically significant." (The lack of a second comma creates ambiguity. A comma after "however" is needed to clearly separate the clauses.)

Example 4 (Correct): "However, further research is needed to validate these findings and explore potential confounding factors." ("However" begins the sentence and is followed by a comma).

Conclusion: Clarity and Consistency are Key

The proper use of commas with "however" is not merely a matter of stylistic preference; it’s a crucial aspect of grammatical precision and clear communication. While there are exceptions depending on sentence structure, the general guideline of using commas on both sides when "however" connects two independent clauses is the safest and most effective approach. By adhering to these rules and paying close attention to context, you can ensure your writing is not only grammatically correct but also easily understood and impactful. Remember, clarity and consistency are paramount in any form of writing, especially when conveying complex ideas or scientific findings.